Image
Agriculture and production of renewable energy in the Western Cape provi...

Project Details

Thematic Project
Reliability
Renewable Energy
Ranjit Deshmukh
Kudakwashe Ndhlukula
Southern Africa
University of California, Santa Barbara
Image
Ranjit Deshmukh UCSB

Ranjit Deshmukh

Principal Investigator
Image
Kudakwashe Ndhlukula SACREEE

Kudakwashe Ndhlukula

Principal Investigator

Renewable energy in Southern Africa 

Accelerating renewable energy in Southern Africa 

 

Background, challenges and context 

Electricity demand in the Southern African Power Pool (SAPP), which consists of 12 member countries (Angola, Botswana, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Eswatini, Lesotho, Mozambique, Malawi, Namibia, South Africa, Tanzania, Zambia, and Zimbabwe) is expected to double by 2040.

Renewable energy technologies are well positioned to meet the anticipated growth in electricity demand. The Southern African region is rich in renewable resources, and with wind and solar technologies declining in cost, they are proving increasingly cost-effective alternatives to conventional generation. Scaling up electricity generation from renewable energy resources will also be an important strategy for meeting climate goals.

However, the Southern African region’s electricity system is dominated by coal and large hydropower. The growth in non-hydro renewable energy generation capacity has significantly lagged behind ambitions and potential, with wind and solar comprising less than 5% of total generation across the 12 countries (South Africa accounts for the largest contribution).

For high renewable energy targets to be pursued, barriers to electricity infrastructure generally – and renewable energy development specifically in the region – will need to be addressed.

Furthermore, optimal energy pathways will need to address the challenge of providing affordable energy to meet rapidly growing electricity demands while not only limiting carbon emissions but also socio-environmental impacts.

 

Research overview and objectives 

This study had two parts. In the first part, the perceived barriers to scaling up renewable energy in the Southern African region were assessed. A complementary suite of approaches – comprising a survey, focus group discussions, and interviews – were employed with energy planners, policy makers, and other stakeholders in the region to capture the range of possible barriers to renewable energy development, identifying themes and trends, and comparing the relative importance of barriers in a systematic way.

In the second part, developable solar photovoltaic (PV) and wind resource locations were investigated, considering not only the best available resource quality, but also other important criteria, such as proximity to transmission infrastructure and load centres, and the conservation value and need for social development in potential locations. The team also assessed how much resource exists based on technical, economic, environmental, and social constraints and opportunities.

The team developed an open-source, electricity planning model for Southern Africa that co-optimised the SAPP power system operations and investments in new generation, transmission, and storage infrastructure, and identified optimal electricity pathways for the region under varying technology and fuel cost projections and energy policies. 

 

Research methodology

To quantitatively determine the relative importance of various barriers, a survey was deployed to 92 energy experts and professionals across 11 SAPP countries (Angola, Botswana, Eswatini, Lesotho, Malawi, Mozambique, Namibia, South Africa, Tanzania, Zambia, and Zimbabwe). 44 completed responses were received.

Participants were presented with statements about potential barriers to renewable energy development and were asked to select responses from a Likert scale (ranging from strongly disagree to strongly agree). The survey questions were developed from a thorough literature review of barriers to renewable energy development generally, as well as in developing countries, in Sub-Saharan Africa, and in SAPP countries specifically. Barriers were grouped into five categories – institutional, financial and economic, technical, social, and environmental.

The team performed various statistical tests to determine if the Likert scale scores significantly differed between different groups of respondents (i.e. country or type of organisation).

Respondents were also given the opportunity to share what they considered to be the top three barriers to renewable energy development in their country or region.

Nine country focus groups were held with representatives from utilities, regulators, ministries of energy, academics, and industry during a decision-support workshop held in South Africa in November 2019. Participants were organised based on the country within which they worked (or if they worked for an international organisation, the country they were most knowledgeable about with respect to the energy sector).

Participants discussed the issues their country or region encountered in developing more renewable energy, and ideas for how power sector planning processes and operations could be improved to address them. The outcomes of the discussions were shared with all participants during the workshop.

The focus group responses were coded, categorised (as institutional, financial and economic, technical, social, or environmental), and either matched with a barrier within the survey or noted as not captured in the survey (i.e. an additional barrier).

From November 2019 through to July 2020, 25 individual, semi-structured interviews were conducted with experts, either in person during the decision-support workshop held in South Africa or via web conference calls. Interviewees were asked for their opinion on 1) the top three challenges or barriers facing utility-scale wind and solar development in their country or region, and suggestions for addressing them, and 2) their biggest concerns about wind and solar development in their country or region.

Transcriptions of the interviews were coded using thematic content analysis to find patterns. The team also used a deductive coding approach by assigning coded barriers to the survey barrier categories and to the closest equivalent barrier in the survey.

In the second part of this study, Southern Africa Renewable Energy Zones were identified. The Multi-criteria Analysis for Planning Renewable Energy (MapRE) tool was used to enable the identification and visualisation of wind and solar renewable energy zones in Southern Africa. The tool allows stakeholders to weight multiple renewable energy siting criteria e.g. generation cost, distance to transmission lines and load centres, and possible environmental impacts – and examine their trade-offs.

Optimal energy pathways for the region’s electricity sector from 2020 to 2040 were developed by leveraging MapRE and combining open source geospatial, hydrologic, and electricity grid-investment models that represented renewable resources in high spatiotemporal detail. The team comprehensively characterised the cost and potential for both renewable and conventional technologies and balanced system costs with greenhouse gas emissions and socio-environmental externalities.

GridPath, an electricity grid analytics platform incorporating capacity expansion and production-cost simulation modelling, was used to co-optimise generation, storage, and transmission investments and their operations across multiple investment periods under different economic and technical constraints. The team also developed a process-based hydrological-water management model, simulating daily river discharge and hydropower production across all existing and planned hydropower plants.

 

Research results, key messages, and recommendations

 

Barriers to scaling up renewable energy

  • The survey, focus group results, and interviews revealed key barriers to renewable energy development in the Southern African region.
  • As a grouping, financial and economic barriers – including high costs of renewable and transmission projects and cost of capital – had the highest level of agreement across respondents for being an important barrier.
  • Respondents identified lack of experience – either in the form of skilled labour or institutional implementation of renewable projects – as important barriers.
  • There was significant disagreement that availability of suitable locations, government selected sites, and profitability are important barriers.
  • Focus groups and open-ended survey responses identified the importance of the need for higher tariffs.
  • Regulators, utilities, and government agencies were the most concerned about social, financial, and technical barriers, while development banks and researchers identified institutional and technical barriers as being the most significant.
  • Adequate financial incentives and better financing terms for renewable energy project developers through international and regional financial institutions are critical to support the initial high costs of wind and solar PV technologies.
  • Similarly, building transmission, especially to interconnect renewable energy projects, is critical to provide access to the tremendous wind and solar resources found across the region.
  • Capacity building, both technical and institutional, will be key to scale up renewable energy development in the region. Importantly, results highlight the critical gap and importance of high-quality renewable resource assessment and integrated resource planning studies, as well as a broader integrated resource planning process.

Addressing these barriers will require significant policy interventions, both from national governments and the international community, especially to reduce the cost of renewable energy and transmission infrastructure through access to technologies, low-cost capital, and subsidies, as well as to create a skilled workforce through training at all levels of the renewable energy industry.

 

Optimal pathways for a low-carbon electricity system

  • The team found that if technology and fuel prices continue to follow current trends, wind and solar technologies can become the dominant sources of electricity in the region by 2040.
  • Importantly, no new coal capacity is required except when inter-regional transmission capacity is constrained.
  • Despite the abundant hydropower potential in the region, fewer than half of planned hydropower projects were cost-competitive, thus supporting river conservation efforts.
  • The alternatives to hydropower appear to be a viable pathway to avoid the socio-environmental impacts of large hydropower projects.
  • Through continued build-out of renewable energy technologies and coordinated expansion of inter-regional transmission lines and electricity trade, Southern Africa could maintain its greenhouse gas emissions in 2040 at 2020 levels.
  • Electricity trade increases 15-30 times across scenarios, highlighting the importance of further developing the inter-regional electricity market.
  • Limiting coal plant lifetimes to 45 years (20 years less compared to reference) could halve emissions, but results in 13% higher total annual system costs.
  • Alternatively, meeting demand with 80% clean energy can halve emissions in 2040 compared to the reference scenario, but costs only 6% more.

This part of the study showed feasible pathways for Southern Africa to develop an affordable and low-carbon electricity system. It included capacity building to ensure stakeholders can understand and use the decision-support tools developed, and can interpret and build on the renewable energy capacity expansion modelling framework. 

The results of the project as a whole can help focus the efforts of stakeholders to accelerate the development and deployment of renewable energy in the Southern African region. The team’s continuous engagement with key stakeholders will ensure the project has an impact on policies and decision making in the renewable energy and overall electricity sector.

 

Local partners

Southern African Development Community (SADC) Centre for Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency (SACREEE)

Regional Electricity Regulators Association of Southern Africa (RERA) 

Southern African Power Pool (SAPP)